Sergii Paliienko
PhD (history), doctoral candidate of the department of archaeology and museum studies Taras Shevchenko National University of Kyiv.
ORCID: 0000-0002-6258-7682
Researcher ID: AAQ-5292-2020
DOI: 10.17721/2522-4611.2021.43.6
PROBLEMS OF ETHNIC HISTORY IN THE SOVIET ARCHAEOLOGY IN
THE 1940S – 1960S: DECLARED PRINCIPLES AND FORMS OF
PRACTICAL REALIZATION
Abstract. The background of institualization of the Soviet theoretical archaeology, which was a subdiscipline and phenomenon existing from the early 1970s till the early 1990s, is one of important topics. A study of ethnogeny and ethnic history problems on the base of archaeological data was one of the main features of the Soviet archaeology in the second half of 1940s – 1960s. That’s why it is actual to recognize which main principles were declared in this field, how they were changed and practically realized.
There are no books dedicated to the history of the Soviet archaeology in the 1940s – 1960s or to the mentioned above topic but certain aspects have been studied by scholars. Sources of this research are publications from the journal “Soviet archaeology” including leading articles and documents from scientific archives of the IA NAS of Ukraine and the IHMC RAS.
The Soviet archaeologists started to work under ethnogeny and ethnic history problems in the middle of the 1930s and researches were going on after the WW2. In the Soviet republics complex archaeological and ethnographic expeditions began their activity and joint sessions with ethnographers and linguists were held for the purpose of complex examination of certain ethnic nationalities
Since the beginning of the 1950s an identification of archaeological cultures, determination of their interrelationship and correlation with ancient language communities were defined as the main way to study ethnic history. This approach was used in researches on almost all periods and was actual at the beginning of the 1970s.
Paleoethnologic problematique was important in activity of central archaeological establishments of the USSR and the UkSSR. Archaeologists were authors of fundamental books on the history of certain folks of the USSR. But during the 1960s these problems were scarcely discussing on methodological workshops of the IA AS USSR and its Leningrad branch and there papers on this topic were almost not presented on meetings of the academic council and departments in Leningrad. That time an ethnical interpretation of archaeological cultures became an obligatory part of fundamental archaeological research that’s why there were discussions only on certain problems. But a difference in approaches of scholars and insufficient elaboration of methodological principles for ethnic history studies aroused interest to theoretical issues which was one of causes of the Soviet theoretical archaeology appearance in the early 1970s.
Key words: history of archaeology, Soviet archaeology, archaeology after WW2, main principles, ethnic history, problems of ethnogeny.
Received by the editorial board: 30.10.2020
REFERENCES:
Abashyna, N.S., Kolesnykova, V.A. (2015). Narysy istorii Instytutu arkheolohii [Outlines of the History of the Institute of Archaeology]. U: Instytut arkheolohii Natsionalnoi akademii nauk Ukrainy. 1918–2014 (pp. 11–98). Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Alekshin, V.A. (1980). Nauchnye soveshchaniya, sessii, simpoziumy, konferentsii, plenumy GAIMK – IIMK – Instituta arkheologii AN SSSR [Scientific Meetings, Sessions, Symposiums, Conferences and Plenums of SAHMC – IHMC – Institute of Archaeology AS USSR]. Kratkie soobshcheniya Instituta arkheologii, 163, 45–51 [in Russian].
Alymov, S.S. (2006). P.I. Kushner i razvitie sovetskoy etnografii v 1920-1950-e gody. [P.I. Kushner and the Development of Soviet Ethnography in the 1920-1950s]. Moscow [in Russian].
Artamonov, M.I. (1951). Trudy tovarishcha Stalina po voprosam yazykoznaniya i sovetskaya arkheologiya [Comrade Stalin’s Works on Problems of Linguistics and the Soviet Archaeology]. Sovetskaya arkheologiya, XV, 7–16 [in Russian].
Vinnik, D.F. (1967). Pyatdesyat let sovetskoy arkheologii v Kirgizii [The Fifty Years of the Soviet Archaeology in Kirgizia]. Sovetskaya arkheologiya, 4, 79–92 [in Russian].
Volkov, V.V. (1980). Institut arkheologii AN SSSR v 50-70-kh godakh [The Institute of Archaeology AS USSR in the 1950s-70s]. Kratkie soobshcheniya Instituta arkheologii, 163, 11–18 [in Russian].
Gaydukov, P.G., Belozerova, I.V., Kuzminykh, S.V. (2019). Iz istorii Instituta arkheologii RAN v 1920–1940-e gody [From the History of the Institute of Archaeology RAS in the 1920s-1940s]. V: Institut arkheologii RAN: 100 let istorii (pp. 11–25). Moscow [in Russian].
Grishin, Yu.S., Maslennikov, A.A. (1978). Metodologicheskiy seminar Instituta arkheologi AN SSSR v 1957 – 1978 gg [The Methodological Workshop of the Institute of Archaeology AS USSR in 1957–1978]. Kratkie soobshcheniya Instituta arkheologii, 152, 92–99 [in Russian].
XXІV sezd KPSS i zadachi sovetskoy arkheologii. (1971). [The ХХІV Congress of the C.P.S.U. and Aims of Soviet archaeology]. Sovetskaya arkheologiya, 4, 3–10 [in Russian].
Zadachi sovetskikh arkheologov v svete trudov I. V. Stalina. (1953). [Tasks of Soviet Archaeologists in the Light of J.V. Stalin’s Works] Sovetskaya arkheologiya, XVІІ, 9–22 [in Russian].
Klejn, L.S. (1993). Fenomen sovetskoy arkheologii [The Phenomenon of Soviet Archaeology]. St.-Petersburg [in Russian].
Moora, Kh.A. (1967). Osnovnye rezultaty arkheologicheskikh issledovaniy v Sovetskoy Estonii [The Main Results of Archaeological Studies in Soviet Estonia]. Sovetskaya arkheologiya, 3, 82–90 [in Russian].
Nashi zadachi v oblasti arkheologicheskikh issledovaniy, v svyazi s resheniyami TsK VKP(b) i Sovnarkoma Soyuza SSR ob uchebnikakh po istorii. (1937). [Our Tasks in the Field of Archaeological Researches in Connection with the Resolution of the C.C. C.P.S.U.(B.) and the Council of Ministers of USSR on History Textbooks]. Sovetskaya arkheologiya, II, 1–15 [in Russian].
Naukovyi arkhiv Instytutu arkheolohii NAN Ukrainy, nerozibranyi dilovodnyi arkhiv, (Razvytye y orhanyzatsyia arkheolohyy Ukraynskoi SSR po sravnenyiu s druhymy stranamy) [Development and Organization of Archaeology in the Ukrainian SSR Comparing to Other Countries], 20 ark. [in Russian].
Naukovyi arkhiv Instytutu istorii materialnoi kultury RAN, f. 312, op. 1., spr. 560. (Otchet o nauchno-yssledovatelskoi rabote LOYA za 1965) [Report on Scientific and Research Work of the Leningrad Branch of IHMC in 1965], 61 ark. [in Russian].
Naukovyi arkhiv Instytutu istorii materialnoi kultury RAN, f. 312, op. 1., spr. 588, (Otchet o nauchno-yssledovatelskoi rabote LOYA za 1966) [Report on Scientific and Research Work of the Leningrad Branch of IHMC in 1966], 57 ark. [in Russian].
Naukovyi arkhiv Instytutu istorii materialnoi kultury RAN, f. 312, op. 1., spr. 707, (Otchet o nauchno-yssledovatelskoi rabote LOYA za 1970) [Report on Scientific and Research Work of the Leningrad Branch of IHMC in 1970], 75 ark. [in Russian].
Paliienko, S.V. (2015). Metodolohichni seminary naukovykh ustanov AN SRSR ta URSR yak zasib rozvytku radianskoi teoretychnoi arkheolohii [Methodological Workshops in Scientific Establishments of the AS USSR and the AS UkSSR as an Instrument of the Soviet Theoretical Archaeology Development]. Materialy i doslidzhennia z arkheolohii Prykarpattia i Volyni, 19, 392–397 [in Ukrainian].
Pyatdesyat let sovetskoy arkheologii. (1967). [The Fifty Years of Soviet Archaeology]. Sovetskaya arkheologiya, 3, 5–8 [in Russian].
Sveshnikova, O.S. (2009). Sovetskie arkheologi v poiskakh pervobytnoy istorii. Istoricheskaya interpretatsiya arkheologicheskikh istochnikov v sovetskoy arkheologii 1930-1950-kh gg. [Soviet Archaeologists in Search of the Primitive History. The Historical Interpretation of Archaeological Sources in Soviet Archaeology in the 1930s-1950s]. Omsk [in Russian].
Sveshnikova, O.S. (2005). Sovetskie arkheologi v poiskakh teorii (po materialam diskussii po dokladu B.B. Piotrovskogo «O zakonomernostyakh v razvitii materialnoy kultury») [Soviet Archaeologists in Search of Theory (on Materials of the Discussion on B.B. Piotrovskiy’s Paper “About Regularities in the Development of Material Culture”)]. V: Arkheologiya Yuzhnoy Sibiri: idei, metody, otkrytiya. Sbornik dokladov mezhdunarodnoy nauchnoy konferentsii, posvyashchennoy 100-letiyu so dnya rozhdeniya S.V. Kiseleva, g. Minusinsk (pp. 250-252). Krasnoyarsk [in Russian].
Simonova, Ye.N. (1962). Obedinennaya sessiya Otdeleniya istoricheskikh nauk AN SSSR i Otdeleniya obshchestvennykh nauk AN USSR (Kiev) [The Joined Session of the Department of Historical Sciences AS USSR and the Department of Social Sciences AS UkSSR (Kiev)]. Kratkie soobshcheniya Instituta arkheologii, 90, 97–105 [in Russian].
Soveshchanie po metodologii etnogeneticheskikh issledovaniy v svete stalinskogo ucheniya o natsii i yazyke. (1951) [The Session on the Methodology of Ethnogenic Studies in the Light of Stalin’s Doctrine of Nation and Language]. Sovetskaya etnografiya, 4, 3–6 [in Russian].
Stubavs, A.Ya. (1967). Arkheologiya v Sovetskoy Latvii (1945- 1967 gg.) [Archaeology in the Soviet Latvia (1945- 1967)]. Sovetskaya arkheologiya, 4, 103–122 [in Russian].
Shnirelman, V.A. (1993). Zloklyucheniya odnoy nauki: etnogeneticheskie issledovaniya i stalinskaya natsionalnaya politika. [A Poor Fate of the Discipline: Ethnogenetic Studies and Stalin's Ethnic Policy] Etnograficheskoe obozrenie, 3, 52–68 [in Russian].
Bulkin, V.A., Klejn, L.S., Lebedev, G.S. (1982). Attainment and problems of Soviet archaeology. World Archaeology, 13, 272–295.
Klejn, L.S. (2012). Soviet archaeology: schools, trends, and history. Oxford.